Sunday, 27 October 2013

GTA5 and the dangers of the one-game business

On release day, I ran to the video game store in my lunch break. Nothing. I shouldn’t have been surprised, there’d been no posters, no advertising for what was unarguably the biggest release of the year. A quick online check confirmed it, GTA5 was not releasing in the UAE (for kind of obvious reasons…). To be honest, I cried a little bit. Inside, obviously. Crying on the outside isn’t allowed in the UAE either. Probably.

Turns out though, that the UAE’s (admittedly rather halfhearted) censorship missed a spot. You can download the game from the PS3 store directly. Booyah!

I’m hardly the only one to get caught up in the hype. Back in the UK, my sister’s work colleagues apparently spent most of that same day stressing about how they would find space on their Xbox hard drives for the game, and the sister herself bought a new Xbox just to play the game. In fact, in total, as I’m sure you know, USD 800mn was spent on GTA5 in its first day. The biggest and fastest selling video game of all time.

But to be honest? It had to be. What? Why? Well because Take 2 (the owners of RockStar – GTA5’s developer) has made a loss for the past 2 years. In fact, TakeTwo lost USD 29mn last year, compared with profits of USD 98mn for EA, and around USD 88mn for Ubisoft (let’s not even go there with Activision…). Looking at it this way, a lot of those big sales numbers for GTA5 are basically paying back all the losses incurred while the game was in development.

However it’s a bit too easy to pin TakeTwo’s previous financial troubles on them taking a long time to finish GTA5. In fact, it’s surprising when you realize all the other well-known franchises the company actually owns. X-Com, Borderlands, Civilization, Bioshock…many of my favorite games from the past year or so, and indeed further back (I first encountered Take 2 with the exceptional Hidden and Dangerous in the days when my family PC was larger than I was). All those well reviewed and critically acclaimed titles bring in some good revenue themselves. Yet TakeTwo’s bottom line still, to be blunt, sucks.

The issue is the huge ‘cost of revenue’ figure (USD 716mn). Even on face value this is big, but as a percentage of revenue its enormous (59%), especially compared to competitors (37% for EA, 34%  Activision, and 27% Ubisoft). Basically, TakeTwo’s games cost around 80% more to make than any of its rivals.

Exactly why that is the case is not spelt out in financials alone, but a couple of things are probably going on.
Firstly, TakeTwo makes critically acclaimed games. Apparently its basketball games are pretty average (I’ve never played them), but Rockstar Games have an average rating of 81 on metacritic, and 2K Games (the second major studio under TakeTwo) has an average of 72.  That kind of consistency and polish costs money. Basically, with the exception of NBA franchise, TakeTwo has limited benefit from the cheap cash cows of updates and rehashes, which underpin sales for the likes of EA.

Secondly, and connected to this is the fact that despite the critical acclaim, these excellent titles don’t actually tend to sell in bucketloads. Bioshock Infinite (many people’s game of the year) sold a total of 2.66mn copies in 2012. Call of Duty Black Ops 2 sold 24.16mn. X-Com sold 160,000 copies since its release this year. Crysis 3 sold 1.44mn for EA in roughly the same period. And when each of these low selling games takes the same level of love and attention, this starts to look like an expensive business model.

Thirdly, and perhaps controversially, TakeTwo still hasn’t really embraced online revenue streams. These are low cost revenue generators like micro transactions, and subscription fees which have underpinned Activison’s revenue for years, and increasingly play a major role for Ubisoft and EA too. This is, presumably, the reason why we are now seeing GTA Online put into the market, to catch up lost ground, but it will take some time before we see how relevant that really is, compared against established online revenue spinners like Fifa’s Ultimate Team, or WoW subscriptions.

Given all of this, TakeTwo can be viewed as something like a premium goods producer, like Aston Martin cars or Mulberry handbags (bear with me). They’re traditional specialists in lovingly crafted items which are appreciated by (or accessible to) only a small part of the market (with the obvious exception of the GTA series). The key difference of course, is that for an Aston Martin car (indeed most luxury goods), that love and attention comes with an equivalent price tag. In the weird world of games on the other hand, premium product tends to sell at roughly the same price as the dross.

That makes this a difficult business model to succeed with, and it’s fairly clear that without GTA to underwrite its other ventures, TakeTwo would have run into serious difficulties. However the happy reality is that they do still have GTA. Most importantly, they still have GTA5’s sudden and enormous revenue influx. The real question is, what can TakeTwo do with those revenues to sustain it over the next 4 years before another GTA title? What can it do to fend off the mass production behemoths of EA, Activision and Ubisoft? Particularly when as recently as 2008, EA was openly pursuing a hostile takeover attempt?
Well, GTA online is a good start (assuming they iron out the bugs), but another big step would be to actually do some research and development. Despite its polished, brilliant games, TakeTwo actually only spends a pitiful 6% of its revenue on R&D. That it’s still able to regularly bring new ideas to the table on such a low budget is impressive, but new Intellectual Property (IP) and new revenue streams such as online distribution require investment. Hopefully, the next annual report from TakeTwo will see a big increase in R&D using the GTA5 funds, with a likely target being increased online revenue. That would be sensible, and it is likely the only way to sustain this kind of business model without compromising TakeTwo’s core strengths. Longer term of course, TakeTwo also needs to find the successor to the GTA franchise when it eventually does run out of steam.

Other than that, standard business principles would suggest cutting down on the number of big budget titles in production (to cut costs), and diversify revenue with a number of smaller projects (perhaps mobile and tablet games as EA is doing) with high margins and high frequency revenue flows. But to be honest, those kind of changes don’t play to TakeTwo’s history. Those kind of moves take it into EA’s territory, which is profitable enough…but that isn’t exactly TakeTwo’s style, it’s not why we buy their games, and it would be a shame if they were forced to go down that route.


Again, I love TakeTwo’s games. Critics love these games. GTA5 is (commercially) the greatest game ever made. Long may that continue, and believe me, I’ll continue buying these games by any means necessary. But putting aside GTA5’s success, TakeTwo somewhat resembles a company of dedicated artisans facing the enormous mechanical industry of its competitors. The bottom line is, that with that old takeover attempt from EA hanging overhead, they need to be very careful with how they re-invest the GTA5 windfall. For the sake of all of our entertainment, my fingers are firmly crossed.

Sunday, 29 September 2013

Pro Evolution Soccer 14 - Realistic empty stadiums

Fifa vs Pro Evo. The great dilemma for all men and boys of a certain age. But now Pro Evo has a new twist to attract your grubby fingers and grubbier money! Localism! Pro Evo is apparently marketing itself in the UAE with the selling point that it includes Arabic language commentary....and local stadiums! Umm…yey?

Honestly, its an interesting move, and one that does make some sense from the boardroom. I can personally see some strong appeal in playing games in an area that simulates the stadium I play my 5 a side in, and the Arabic commentary is fairly low hanging fruit for any sports game. It’s also been my very anecdotal evidence that Pro Evo does need to do something in the Middle East. Most of my friends simply react with bemusement to the idea of playing something other than Fifa, assuming they don’t react with blank looks to the name Pro Evo anyway.

So, on paper, this seems like an obvious win for the boys at Konami....except its not.

Local football in the UAE is both tiny, and terrible. While there are a few aging stars from the European leagues, they are heavily subsidised by the government, with audiences of a few hundred at the most. Yes, sure some of us get to play  five a side in the stadia, but in general the amount of people likely to get excited by, or even recognise these locations are going to be tiny. Any amount of research would have told Konami this. In fact,lets broaden this to make some nice generalisations. The Middle East is football mad (Check Al Jazeera's Permier League viewership stats). But with very few exceptions (cough…Egypt) the local teams are terrible. The consequence? Idolisation of European clubs beyond all reason. There is a reason that the list of clubs opening ‘training camps’ in the UAE is lengthening every day. Emiratis don’t want to simulate playing in the stadium next door. They want to simulate playing in the Bernabeu, the Nou Camp, Old Trafford. Which is where Fifa still has the edge, with its fully licensed stadiums and team names.

Of course this doesn’t address the question of which game is better to play. And to be honest, it doesn’t matter. One of the most important bits of any football game these days is the multiplayer. If your friends play Fifa, you will too, so long as there aren't obviously huge flaws. Which effectively indicates where Konami should be focusing their attention, rather than these pointless local flourishes. They still havent cracked that online multiplayer. I was introduced to Fifa's online ’Ultimate Team’ mode in Fifa 12 and was instantly hooked, despite previously being a passionate Pro Evo fan. Two editions later and Pro still has nothing to compete with this, regardless of how good those core gameplay mechanics might be now. For a region like the GCC which is ever more internet focused, cracking that online multiplayer is always going to be far more important to driving local adoption than un-researched and empty gestures to a non-existent localised support base.